Click here to download this page as a pdf document


The chart below, prepared by the Center for Medicare Advocacy, provides a helpful, non-threatening and factual side-by-side comparison of the American health care system as it exists today and how it could improve under some of the health reform proposals currently being discussed by Congress. 

 

In addition, the piece describes a successful government sponsored public health insurance option that has been in operation in the United States since 1965--Medicare.  It talks about how the privatization of the Medicare program over the past nine years (such as through the proliferation of Medicare Advantage plans and the Part D prescription drug programs) has drained billions of dollars out of the Medicare program—money that could have been used to pay for and improve services to Medicare beneficiaries. Instead this money helped make the drug and insurance industries the profitable organizations they are today.    

 

If you think this would be helpful, please send to locals and members as another background tool to use when discussing health care reform. 

 

CMA

 

 

www.medicareadvocacy.org

WEEKLY ALERT

August 13, 2009

Read or Print Online
Click on the link above to view this and past Alerts on our website, or to print out the Alert (note: .pdf versions require the Adobe¨ reader)

CMA Health Policy Consultants
Innovative legal and technical consulting, and health policy expertise supporting systems that work.

News Page
More information on this and many other current health care topics

Products & Services
The Center for Medicare Advocacy offers educational materials, handbooks, seminars and more

Donate to the Center
Help the Center for Medicare Advocacy to help elders and people with disabilities

Beneficiary Forum
Share your thoughts or stories on Medicare, health insurance, and related issues, and view those of others

www.medicareadvocacy.org
Access all our online information and services


COUNTERING HEALTH REFORM MISINFORMATION


As the debate over health care reform continues, special interest groups have begun spreading rumors and misinformation designed to make the public doubt, or even fear, reform. Below are real facts about our current system and proposed reforms.

Why Health Reform Works for You

Our Current System

Proposed Health Reform

You currently have health insurance through

  • Your employer
  • Medicare
  • Medicaid
  • VA
  • The military
  • Other

You will be able to keep the health insurance that you have.

You may be, or may become, uninsured:

  • Your employer can change or end your health insurance coverage at any time;
  • You lose your job and are not eligible for or can't afford COBRA health care continuation insurance;
  • You do not have insurance through your work place;
  • You cannot afford private insurance or no private insurance company will sell you a policy.

You will be able to purchase health insurance through a Health Insurance Exchange:

You will have a number of health plans from which to choose;

If you have limited income, you will receive assistance with the cost of the premium.

You have a pre-existing condition:

  • Health insurance companies can refuse to sell you health insurance;
  • If health insurance companies sell you insurance, they may not cover services they decide are related to the pre-existing condition.

You have a pre-existing condition:

  • Health insurance plans will not be able to deny you insurance;
  • Health insurance plans will not be able to deny coverage of claims based on pre-existing conditions.

Health insurance companies can charge you a higher premium based on:

  • Gender;
  • Health status.

Health insurance plans will NOT be able to charge you higher premiums based on:

  • Gender
  • Health Status

Health insurance plans can charge exorbitant out-of-pocket expenses:

  • High deductibles;
  • High co-pays;
  • Limits on how much they will pay in a year and over a lifetime.

There will be limits on out-of-pocket costs:

  • No cost-sharing for preventive care;
  • Annual out-of-pocket caps;
  • No annual or lifetime limits on how much coverage your insurance will provide.

Insurance premiums and health care costs are rising rapidly.

Mechanisms will be in place to help contain costs;

  • A public health insurance option that competes with private plans will keep costs low as it encourages innovation and efficiency in health care.
  • Other health system reforms, including a focus on prevention and coordination of health care, will help reduce costs.

Medicare IS Public Health Insurance

44 years ago Medicare was enacted into law. All of today's dire warnings about a public health option - socialism and government barring the doctor's door - were made in opposition to Medicare. Despite such opposition from "conservative," leaders, Medicare passed because of some courageous, principled law-makers.

Before Medicare, 50% of everyone 65 or older had NO health insurance. Now, as a result of Medicare, almost all older people are insured. Medicare, which is national, government-run health insurance, succeeded in insuring older people where private insurance failed. Further, until the Bush Administration privatized Medicare with huge subsidies to private "Medicare Advantage" and Part D plans, Medicare was also remarkably cost-effective. It's private Medicare, not the traditional, public program, that's bleeding taxpayers of billions of dollars.

Medicare has been a success, fiscally and morally. It took on the job of insuring health coverage and care to people that private insurance had abandoned. Since 2003, on the other hand, private Medicare plans have cost us all tens of billions of dollars that went to support the private insurance industry, not to providing health care. In addition, private Medicare plans have too often engaged in marketing abuses and restrictive coverage practices.

As numerous studies have shown, people with Medicare love it. They do not want government to fool around with the traditional program. Ironically, some people with Medicare are arguing against a public health care reform option - while also telling the government "to keep its hands-off their Medicare!" They, and their family members, (which accounts for pretty much all of us), forget that the traditional Medicare program is a public health insurance option.

Meet Medicare: Our 44 year-old public health insurance option that provides care to all its enrollees everywhere in the country, and that has provided health and economic security for millions of older people, people with disabilities, and their families. For two generations, the public Medicare program has shown what a true public insurance program can offer: health insurance for the otherwise uninsured, at a price that taxpayers can afford.

Now, for all generations, we need a public option in health reform!

For more information, contact executive director Judith Stein in the Center for Medicare Advocacy's Connecticut office at (860) 456-7790.


Learn from Medicare: Support real health reform; support a public plan!

CMA Health Policy Consultants

Have more to say? Blog about it!

If you feel you have received this message in error, would like an address corrected, or would like to add an address, please contact Matthew Shepard. This Alert is formatted. It is best viewed full-screen. If you would like to receive a text-only version of this alert, please reply to this message with the subject "text only". Alerts are also available here, through the "News" page.

Copyright 2009 Center for Medicare Advocacy, Inc.
www.medicareadvocacy.org

Matthew E. Shepard
Publications Coordinator
Center for Medicare Advocacy, Inc.
PO Box 350
Willimantic, CT 06226
mshepard@medicareadvocacy.org
(860) 456-7790 (860) 456-2614 (fax)

The information in this electronic communication is intended only for the use of the individual(s) or entity named above, and may be legally privileged and confidential under applicable law. If the recipient of this message is not the above-named intended recipient(s), you are hereby notified that any dissemination, copy or disclosure of this communication is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, please notify the sender above and purge the communication immediately without making any copy or distribution.